Our Story

Our family has been in the Pizza, Italian Cuisine, Food Industry for years. Starting out a little over 45 years ago, Cosmo Boniello (father of Tony Boniello) started the tradition. Tony Boniello learned the culinary skills of his family, took what he learned & passed it on to his wife & daughters.

We hope you feel at home in our little cozy restaurant. We cook like we're in our kitchen at home, & entertain as if you are all already our friends & family. Come enjoy our food, we'll become great friends & you'll quickly learn how our friends turn into family. We hope to see you soon! Come eat with us!


Due to our size and high demand, we do not take reservations.

Guests will be seated on a first come, first served basis when all members of the party are present. We do our best to seat you and your complete party as efficiently as possible based upon party size. 


Boniello's offers offsite catering for all types of celebrations. Feel free to take a look at our catering menu here. If you have any questions in regards to catering please feel free to email us at theboniellofamily@gmail.com

In House Party

Boniello's offers onside in-house parties for all types of celebrations. 

For inquiries for inhouse parties please email us at theboniellofamily@gmail.com


Bring your own & bring some for us! Don't forget, if you finish your bottle or would like to leave your "cork" at Boniello's, ask for a marker & a cork to leave your mark! 


Phone 973-831-0222



Email theboniellofamily@gmail.com

  • Facebook Grunge
  • Twitter Grunge
  • Instagram Grunge

72 Hamburg Turnpike

Riverdale, NJ 07457


Across from Sunoco, 
​Next to Mike's Feed Farm,


Tues – Sat 11AM - 7:30PM

Sunday  3PM - 7:30PM

Monday  Closed

© 2023 by City Bakery. Proudly created with Wix.com